Material Guides

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Shingle roofed home compared with metal roofing options by Roofing Bay Area CA across the region

Key takeaway

Asphalt shingles cost less upfront ($900–$1,700 per square) and last 25–30 years. Standing seam metal costs more ($1,900–$3,500 per square) but lasts 40–70 years, offers Class A fire performance and suits solar. For owners staying 15+ years, metal usually delivers better long-term value.

It is the most common question we hear from Bay Area homeowners planning a reroof. Here is a straight comparison.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorAsphalt shinglesStanding seam metal
Installed cost / sq$900 – $1,700$1,900 – $3,500
Lifespan25 – 30 years40 – 70 years
Fire ratingClass A assembly (many)Class A assembly
WeightLightVery light
SolarFlashed mountsClamp-on, no penetrations
MaintenanceLow to moderateLow
LookTraditionalModern or traditional

When Shingles Make Sense

  • Shorter ownership horizon
  • Tighter upfront budget
  • HOA requires shingles
  • Traditional look desired

When Metal Makes Sense

  • Staying 15+ years
  • Wildfire hazard zone
  • Planning solar
  • Want the last roof you buy

Explore asphalt shingle roofing or metal roofing for homes.

Frequently asked questions

Is metal louder than shingles?

Not with a solid deck and insulated attic.

Which is better for resale?

Both sell well; metal’s longevity and fire resistance are increasingly valued.

Which is more energy efficient?

Reflective metal finishes typically reduce attic heat more than standard shingles.

Compare Both on Your Home

Get side-by-side shingle and metal estimates.

Free, no-obligation estimates

Ready to Protect Your Roof?

Get a written, line-item estimate with photos of your roof — usually within 48 hours. Leaking right now? Our emergency line is answered 24/7.

Call NowFree Estimate